data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/acd70/acd70a29a4d18aa0e40086ba73efafca63cbfd49" alt=""
Dancers spend a lot of time on Youtube watching as many videos as we can, so when one of my students mentioned a dance film I hadn't seen, I was a little surprised. But after he sent me the link, I spent probably the better part of an hour watching clips of
David Kinsella's beautiful and yet highly disturbing film. "A Beautiful Tragedy" follows the progress of a 15-year old girl named Oksana Skorik, a student at the famed
Perm State Ballet School -- a place which has turned out some of the world's most refined dancers.
It's not unlike watching a terrible tragic accident: so upsetting that you can't look away.
In pursuit of a career in dance, (as much for her mother as for herself) Oksana works, starves, battles loneliness, and takes heaps of verbal abuse from her teachers, notably Lidiya Ulanova, who calls the girls idiots and angrily tells them they're insolent and stuffed dummies.
"Why would a teacher do that?" wonders my student aloud. "What kind of a person is that?"
I have no good answers. But almost more disturbing is the thought that so many people think this is the way to make good dancers. Skorik went into the Kirov Ballet, and her classmate Masha Menchikova went to the Perm company. Success came to them, but how much more beautiful could they have been without the abuse?
Clip 1Clip 2Clip 3Clip 4You can order the film in both NTSC and PAL formats from
Faction Film.