Tuesday, March 31, 2009

The critic gets criticized

Interesting letter to the Chronicle today criticizing my criticism:

Editor - Having read the dance reviews of newly adopted dance critic Mary Ellen Hunt over the past couple months, I am dismayed at the improper and outdated direction in which The Chronicle is channeling its dance criticism. Hunt's articles offer little more than eloquent narratives of the works she is 'reviewing.'

When you look beyond the veil of her elaborate use of long descriptive words that she strings together in a poetic phrases you can see that there is almost no actual reviewing involved in her writings. In the past several decades much literature on the nature and purpose of dance criticism has been published, yet it seems that only a few dance critics and no newspaper editor outside of New York City have stumbled upon it.

Dance criticism has evolved to a much greater level than dealing with summaries and description as is characteristic of Hunt's writings. It has now been shown that it's possible to add a level of intelligent analysis to a review! If a dance review doesn't address the values of a piece of art (why was it made, why is it deserving of a review, how it adds to or advances the art form, how it challenges convention, how it directs culture) the review offers little contribution and is nearly pointless.

By only offering description and summaries of works in your dance reviews you are not cultivating an audience of intelligent viewers who will be inspired to engage in seeing dance or even continue reading your articles, you are only cultivating an audience who knows how to appreciate a well-worded summary. Having been a professional dancer and pursuing academic dance research, I am constantly frustrated at how rarely the general public approaches dance with intelligent thought.

- Elliot Gordon Mercer


Mercer, who danced with Company C, seems to have a very particular idea of what critics writing for a daily newspaper should be doing. So what do you think out there?

Read more at the SF Chronicle site.

Monday, March 23, 2009

Deer Hollow Farm: Chance to pet animals on tours

With spring in the air, there's no better time to visit Deer Hollow Farm, which welcomes new lambs and kids - the goat-y kind - to their charming menagerie of pigs, chickens, rabbits, ducks and geese with spring farm tours.

Read more at the SF Chronicle website.


Tuesday, March 17, 2009

Miller-McCune | Article | Fine Arts Journalism Faces Bleak Future with Entrepreneurial Verve

With newspaper vanishing, Tom Jacobs wonders where the critics will go. (I know some people will have their own tart response to that question!)
"A former staff writer with the Seattle Post-Intelligencer (the industry's most recent print casualty, which became an online-only product as of March 17) and Seattle Weekly, McLennan also heads the scaled-back National Arts Journalism Program, and in that capacity he has been tracking some disturbing figures. He estimates that in 2005, there were approximately 5,000 staff positions on American newspapers that involved writing about the arts. These include critics, feature writers, reporters who cover cultural news — and the many journalists who juggle all three of those roles."

Today, he estimates that due to layoffs, cutbacks and the closure of several prominent papers (including, another recent victim, Denver's Rocky Mountain News), that number is down to 2,500. That's a 50 percent decline in only four years — a disproportionate loss even for an industry in decline. (Advertising Age recently estimated that one newspaper job in four has been lost since 1990.) Sean Means, film critic of the Salt Lake City Tribune, is independently keeping a running tally of colleagues who have been laid off over the past three years. The total is up to 49.

Most newspapers continue to cover the world of culture using freelancers and (in the case of film and television) wire-service copy to supplement the remaining staff. A few, including the Los Angeles Times, have inaugurated blogs on their Web sites to get arts news out more quickly."

Read more at Miller-McCune.

Monday, March 16, 2009

Dance Review: Los Farruco at the Palace of Fine Arts

Los Farruco's stunning one-night-only show at the Festival of Flamenco Arts and Traditions at the Palace of Fine Arts Theater on March 6 had to have been one of the Bay Area flamenco community's most highly anticipated performances. So I was surprised in the week after to find out that so few people outside of the flamenco circles even knew that the family Farruco was even performing -- how did it not register on the mainstream dance community's radar?

Even so, pesented by the Bay Area Flamenco Partnership, Los Farruco easily sold the Palace of Fine Arts theater out. The lobby was jammed, and even a last minute snafu with the online ticketing service didn't deter patrons, who waited forty-five minutes for the show to start under chaotic circumstances to say the least. But then, we are talking about one of the world's leading exponents of flamenco puro, and a family of artists descended from the legendary El Farruco, whose grandson Farruquito seared his presence onto the stage at the Flamenco Festival USA with Juana Amaya back in 2003.

Perhaps anticipation of the family's tour was fanned by the release of the 2005 film "Bodas de Gloria," which chronicles the lives of a gypsy clan, in a sort of retort to the violent panache of "Blood Wedding." Farruquito--Juan Manuel Fernandez Montoya, who did not appear on this tour, but apparently helped to produce it-- stars in the drama which was filmed back in 1996, but of equal note were the appearances by El Farruco's daughters, Rosario Montoya "La Farruca" (Farruquito's mother) and Pilar Montoya "La Faraona" and the debut of young Antonio Fernandez Montoya, Farruquito's younger brother, who would take on the name "El Farruco" after his grandfather's death in 1997. These three, La Farruca, La Faraona and El Farruco the younger were joined by La Faraona's son "El Barullo," for an electrifying evening.

If all of that seems confusing, perhaps it's enough to understand that this was a family affair, and that for a few hours, it felt as though you'd been invited into the Farruco family for a glimpse of what life looks like in the eye of the surging storm that their intensity whips up. The show is still a show--this is entertainment of the first-order, but beyond that, it feels personal. These musicains and dancers have something to say--to each other, to us, to a higher power. They have the tools to put that conversation across, and nothing is so satisfying as being a part of that, whether you're onstage or not.

A smoky air hangs over the stage when the curtain finally goes up to reveal guitarist Antonio Rey Navas alone on the stage, playing in cascading ebbs and flows to a theater so silent and rapt that under the strains of a solo you could hear him taking breaths.

But it isn't long before the guys, Barullo and Farruco burst onto stage, roiling with youthful vigor. Clad in simple black pants, a white shirt and red scarf at the throat, they face off, attacking the ground, attacking the music, and you think to yourself, ah the energy of youth. Then La Farruca arrives.

For a moment, the boys look as though they're daring her to take them on... poor mama. Then she unleashes an unsuspected fury...poor boys. La Farruca has a wild feral quality, a tempestuousness, that takes her fearlessly off balance, and yet which she completely controls. In about two minutes her hair is out of a neat chignon and the energy coursing from the singers to the dancers and back is palpable, like an electric current -- you can't take your finger out of the socket.

With the audience still breathing hard after that last encounter, Rey returns, this time accompanying the singers (Antonio Zuniga, Simon de Malaga, Mara Rey and Pedro el Granaino), and the rasp of brings back to me the images of a singer in Granada leaning off an iron balcony above a crowd of hundreds, singing to the Virgin during Holy Week.

The terrifically commanding Mara Rey leads the entrance of a rotund woman with a capacious bosom covered in red silk for the bulerias. Faraona is a force to be reckoned with, even with a bandage on her hand and the audience goes crazy as though we're imploring her to dance, literally shrieking for her to continue.

As Barullo returns, in a rust-colored suit with a long jacket that he flourishes like a shawl, for his Seguiriya, the shouts begin anew. He turns so impossibly off balance that it nearly looks like acrobatics, but from the audience, a woman shouts in Spanish, and the only word I make out is "duende." In response, a faint smile turns up the corner of Barrullo's lips as he rips off the jacket and gets busy charging into ridiculously complex rhythms.

Mercurially, the mood changes again for Farruco's solea and he enters upstage like a shadowy ghost behind the cantaor. Tall and slender, he takes his time, hands capturing the air, moving slowly with sturm und drang washing all around him. Then suddenly, he is like a man unleashed on life, with lustiness and perhap even petulance coming out in lightning blasts of zapateado.

La Farruca returns for the romanza, cutting a stunning silhouette in a long dark dress. With just the hands curled into fists, and her long hair continually escaping its bounds, she looks possessed. She gets all up into the singers' grille, inspires extra energy from them and in a display of dictatorial pique, stomps the ground with a force that conveys a temperament that is at once inexorable and inextinguishable.

As the jaleos draw to a close, the family Farruco takes their bows but fromthe mood of the crowd on its feet and stomping themselves, it can't be over. For an encore, the musicians, singers and dancers all come out onto the apron of the stage and Farruco rips a chair free from its microphone wires and sets it downstage for guitarists Rey and El Tuto to lean on. Now is the time for everyone to dance, even their lighting designer comes out in sneakers and takes a turn with them. Nobody leaves without dancing.


Sunday, March 15, 2009

Dance review: ODC's 'Grassland,' 'Forest'

Questing and discovery loosely tied together two very different premieres at the ODC/Dance Downtown 2009 season, which opened with a gala performance Thursday evening, and which continues at the Novellus Theater in Yerba Buena Center through March 29.

At the heart of KT Nelson's "Grassland" - a new work set to a commissioned score by Marcelo Zarvos, and accompanied by Zarvos on piano along with a live string quartet under the direction of René Mandel - is a herd of wild things, pulsing with life.

Read more at the SF Chronicle site.

Saturday, March 7, 2009

Dance review: David Rousseve's 'Saudade'

There are many words whose finer nuances escape exact translation into English, and yet there remains the sense that you can grasp the essence through the lens of experience, stories or analogies. Saudade is translated from the Portuguese variously as nostalgia or bittersweet longing, and David Rouss�ve's thoughtfully constructed dance-theater work 'Saudade' - a co-commission from the Yerba Buena Center for the Arts that opened at the Novellus Theater on Thursday night - attempts to get to the heart of the word with tales that reflect intermingling sadness and joy.

Read more at the SF Chronicle website.

Thursday, March 5, 2009

'Invasion of the Land Animals': March program

Known for its mesmerizing walk-through tunnel-tanks that show off elegant swirls of sardines, lazing rockfish, giant sea bass and a dizzying variety of rays and sharks, the Aquarium of the Bay has long appealed to young oceanographers-in-training. Dedicated to educating the public about conservation issues, the Aquarium is now expanding its sights to include land-dwellers such as the Pacific tree frog and the western toad, which kids can see up close during a special preview on Sunday.

Frogs and toads, long considered barometers of the planet's ecological health, are among the creatures most sensitive to changes in climate patterns. The aquarium's Invasion of the Land Animals programs, which take place each weekend in March, lead up to the opening on April 4 of the PG&E Bay Lab, an interactive exhibition on climate change as well as exhibits on the giant Pacific octopus and moon jellies. Aquarium organizers hope that the new lab will help introduce kids to conservation issues and put a face on the victims of global warming.

Read more at The SF Chronicle Website.


Sunday, March 1, 2009

Ailey's humanistic vision touches the world

Although Alvin Ailey died in 1989, people who work at Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater tend to speak about the company's founder in the present tense: 'The most important thing to Mr. Ailey is that we be grounded human beings'; 'Alvin has always been a man of big dreams.'

That he remains a living presence to the people of the Alvin Ailey company is not only striking, but it also seems to be the singular reason for the extraordinary growth and longevity of the organization that he founded, which celebrates its 50th anniversary with three Cal Performances programs this week at UC Berkeley.

Keep reading at the SF Chronicle website.